Electric Motorized Ball Valve Vs.Solenoid Ball Valve?

In this blog post, you’ll read:Technology has made our lives easier. For plumbing or HVAC purposes, using a valve brings a great change to the whole system. A valve is a control device. It can control fluid, air, or gas in any system. Nowadays, valves are useful for domestic, even astronomy purposes.
Table of Contents

Introduction of Valve

Technology has made our lives easier. Using a valve significantly changes the whole system for plumbing or HVAC purposes. A valve is a control device. It can control fluid, air, or gas in any system. Nowadays, valves are helpful for domestic and even astronomy purposes.

What’s a Solenoid Valve & Electrical Motorized Valve

A solenoid valve is a directional control valve that works without any motor. The Solenoid is an electromagnetic coil. It can control the current through the valve. When an electric current runs through a solenoid, it will generate a magnetic field. This magnetic field helps to move the plunger & open the valve. It is a coil set, a valve body, a pilot head, and a rubber pad.

A motorized ball valve is a valve with a motor. This valve works by the rotation of the motor shaft. Some of them can be opened or closed manually. It regulates the analog quantity of the flow of liquid, gas, and air system pipelines. These valves are AI-controlled.

Motorized ball valves consist of a single-phase servo motor & a servo controller. There is also a drive screw & a position limit switch.

The changing time of the directional control valve is low. We turn it on or off in one second. The motorized valve on/off time isn’t so standard.

We can control the Motorized Valve opening smoothly. We can open, close, half-open, or half-close the valve. Solenoid valves can’t meet this necessity.

The solenoid valve doesn’t need any reset device. It has a particular function that can be reset during power cuts. The motorized ball valve needs a reset device.

https://youtu.be/M6n5TsR38GQ
From EcoNet Controls

Types of Solenoid Valve

Two-way, Three-way, and four-way Solenoid Valves.

A two-way valve has two ways to connect with the source. These are inlet & outlet. These valves can operate either open or close.

The three-way solenoid valve has three control settings. Normal closed, normally open, and general type. These valves can scatter the flow through different ports.

A four-way solenoid valve acts like a double-acting cylinder. It consists of one or two exhaust ports, two-cylinder ports, a pressure port, and a few connectors.

1. Quarter turn valve

2. Multi-turn valve 

3. Linear motorized valve

The quarter-turn motorized valve uses a 90° turn. It helps to open and close a port.

Actuators use balls, gates, or other tools for multi-turn motorized valves. It helps to open and close the valves.

A linear valve works with control or diaphragm valves. It occurs through the movement of fluid.

solenoid valve
solenoid valve

Construction Materials Of solenoid Valve & Motorized Electric Ball Valve

Solenoid valves are devices of stainless steel and brass options. These valves use bronze, carbon steel, stainless steel & PVC. Some solenoid valves are Polypropylene and alloys.

The construction of motorized ball valves is diverse.

Different In Leakage Issue

Solenoid valves cause leakage because of contaminations in the medium.

The basic of a motorized valve is angle stroke. Its sealing is double-sided. So, leakage is not so easy.

functions check
functions check

Fitting Position Of Solenoid Valve & Electrical Motorized Ball Valve

The working principle of a solenoid valve is a straight stroke. So we have to install a valve horizontally. Other types of installation may cause leakage.

You can install a motorized valve as the system fits.

Comparison Of Lifespan & Protection

A common failure of a Solenoid valve is long-time coil burning. Sometimes, long-time coil burning is essential for electrifying the coil. But it reduces longevity.

A motorized Valve has a longer service life than a solenoid valve. It performs stable.

A Solenoid valve has a low protection level. External dust, air, and temperature can affect Solenoid Valves.

A motorized Ball Valve is more protective than a Solenoid Valve.

Suitable Medium For Solenoid Valve& Electric Ball Valve

Solenoid valves are ideal for acid, water, gas, and steam. But the condition is that there should not be any impurities. We can set up a filter in front of the valve. It can ensure a low leakage rate.

A motorized valve is appropriate for controlling the fluid medium containing fiber.

You can use solenoid valves with Alternating Current or Direct Current, and Solenoid Valve has a simple design. Power consumption is relatively low. They need no power to hold ordinarily open or normally closed positions.

To hold a position, solenoid valves need continuous power. It may cause heat within the coils. Valves will be burned out if left in the on position for too long.

The Solenoid doesn’t have manual overrides. We must consider the water-hammer potential from rapid closing.

There are limitations for backpressure and inlet pressure based on the size and design of the valve.

Almost all the solenoid valves work with a plunger; unwanted particles & debris may cause a huge problem. It allows the valve to leak. In this case, motorized valves can handle random debris. They don’t seal with a diaphragm.

We can use a solenoid valve only for small pipe control. Electric ball valves are often used in large pipelines. They can regulate the management of pipelines.

Merits And Demerits Of Motorized Ball Valves

Motorized Ball Valves work with a high flow rate. The value of ‘heat capacity at constant volume’ (Cv) is very high.

These valves are easy to install. Integration into automation systems is also easy for motorized ball valves. The operating cost of an electrically motorized ball valve is much less. Solenoid valves need a continuous power supply, and it’s costly; these valves permit high inlet pressure & high back pressure.

One should consider water hammer potential. It happens at a high flow capacity.

Internal component damage is a big issue for motorized ball valves. The ball is machined precisely. Damage to the ball may cause the valve to be useless. Servicing is not a solution in this case.

The construction of a motorized valve is not simple. The circuit required to run the valve is also complex. Its failure rate is lower.

We know that the electric actuator has a large torque. This torque can control large pipe diameters and large flow.

Solutions For Waterworks Plumbing

Get quote Now

Free Sample with OEM

× How can I help you?